Xero Mesa Trail II Review: Is This the Ultimate Barefoot Trail Shoe?

Here are the main things to know about the Xero Mesa Trail II after putting them through their paces on the trails.

Key Takeaways

• The Mesa Trail II offers a great minimalist feel with good ground connection.
• Traction is solid on most dry and moderately wet surfaces, but struggles in deep mud or snow.
• The shoe fits true to size with a roomy toe box, though some might find the forefoot a bit loose.
• They are lightweight and breathable, making them comfortable for long runs.
• While durable, they aren’t the best choice for extreme weather or runners needing lots of support.

Xero Mesa Trail II: First Impressions And Design

Aesthetically Pleasing Trail Shoe

The Xero Mesa Trail II definitely catches the eye. It sports a clean look that doesn’t scream “technical gear” but rather a more casual, yet capable, trail shoe.

The design team opted for a blend of durable overlays and breathable mesh, giving it a modern appearance. It strikes a nice balance between looking good and being ready for the dirt. The overall impression is one of understated capability, making it a shoe you wouldn’t mind wearing even when you’re not on the trail.

Low Profile, Zero Drop Advantage

One of the most noticeable aspects of the Mesa Trail II is its low profile. This design choice is central to the minimalist philosophy Xero Shoes champions. A low stack height means your foot stays closer to the ground, which can be a real advantage on uneven terrain.

It helps reduce the leverage that can lead to ankle twists, especially on rocky or uneven surfaces. This design is a key part of what gives you that barefoot feel that many minimalist runners seek. It’s a design that encourages a more natural foot placement and movement, which is a big plus for those looking to connect more with the trail.

Upgraded Components For Version Two

When Xero Shoes released the Mesa Trail II, they didn’t just slap a new number on it; they made some thoughtful upgrades. The outsole received a new rubber compound, aiming for better grip and durability.

The overlays on the upper have also been redesigned to be more robust, offering better protection without adding significant weight. These refinements aim to build on the success of the original model, making an already popular shoe even better for trail running. It’s good to see a company listen to feedback and improve their products, and these updates seem to do just that.

Performance On The Trail

Tread And Traction Capabilities

The Xero Mesa Trail II really shines when it comes to its outsole. The FeelTrue™ rubber, featuring 3.5mm lugs, provides a surprisingly good grip across various surfaces.

While it might not be the absolute grippiest shoe on the market, it strikes a solid balance. You get a confident connection to the ground without feeling like your feet are glued down. This is a big step up from the original Mesa Trail, especially on descents. The added rubber underfoot, without sacrificing too much ground feel, makes tackling rocky downhills much safer and faster. It feels like they found a sweet spot between protection and that natural barefoot sensation.

Handling Varied Terrain

This shoe handles a wide range of trail conditions admirably. From rolling hills and gravel paths to rooty sections and even some light scrambling, the Mesa Trail II feels capable. The flexibility of the sole is a standout feature; it bends and twists in multiple directions, mimicking how your foot naturally moves.

This articulation, combined with the protective overlays around the shoe, means you can confidently tackle uneven ground. It’s not designed for extreme conditions like deep mud or packed ice, but for the everyday trail runner, it covers a lot of bases. You can really feel connected to your world when you run in these.

Grip In Less Than Ideal Conditions

When the weather turns less than perfect, the Mesa Trail II still holds its own. While not specifically a waterproof shoe, the breathable mesh uppers do a decent job of shedding light moisture.

In terms of traction, the lug pattern offers reliable grip on wet grass and even in damp mud, though it can collect some in the arch area. The low-profile design keeps you stable, and the outsole compound seems to perform well even when things get a bit slick. Just remember, for truly slushy or snowy conditions, you might want to consider something more specialized.

Fit And Feel Of The Mesa Trail II

True To Size Fit

When it comes to sizing, the Xero Mesa Trail II generally runs true to size. Most runners find that ordering their usual shoe size works out well. It’s always a good idea to check any sizing charts Xero provides, but based on feedback, you’re likely safe sticking with what you normally wear. This makes the online buying process a bit less of a gamble, which is nice.

Roomy Toe Box Considerations

One of the hallmarks of Xero Shoes is their foot-shaped, wider toe box, and the Mesa Trail II is no exception. This design allows your toes to splay naturally, which is great for balance and comfort, especially on uneven terrain. For those with wider feet or a significant toe splay, this roomy toe box is a major plus.

However, some users with narrower feet might find the forefoot feels a little slushy or less secure than they’re used to. It’s a trade-off for natural foot movement, and it’s something to be aware of. Customers often praise this ample toe room, noting it helps maintain comfort on longer runs.

Secure Midfoot And Heel Lockdown

While the forefoot is generous, the midfoot and heel offer a surprisingly secure lockdown. The adjustable midfoot and instep straps, part of the ‘Huarache’ inspired lacing system, really hug your foot. When you pull the tabs, these overlays snug down, keeping your foot firmly in place.

This is important for trail running, preventing excessive movement inside the shoe, especially on descents or when navigating technical sections. The heel cup is also well-structured without being overly rigid, providing a stable base without causing irritation. This combination of a spacious toe box and a secure midfoot is what makes the Mesa Trail II feel so balanced and capable on the trails.

Strengths Of The Xero Mesa Trail II

The Xero Mesa Trail II really shines when it comes to giving you that connected-to-the-ground feeling without leaving your feet feeling beat up. It strikes a great balance, which is pretty neat for a minimalist shoe.

Exceptional Ground Feel

This is where the Mesa Trail II truly excels. You get a fantastic sense of what’s underfoot, allowing your feet to react naturally to the terrain.

It’s not so much that you’re feeling every single pebble, but you’re aware of the trail in a way that helps with agility and confidence. This shoe lets your feet do their thing. It’s a big part of why people are drawn to minimalist footwear in the first place, and Xero Shoes nails it here. It’s a feeling that’s hard to describe until you’ve experienced it on a run.

Durable Protection Underfoot

While it offers amazing ground feel, don’t think your feet are unprotected. The sole provides just enough cushioning and durability to handle rocky or rooty trails without causing discomfort.

You get that minimalist experience without the constant worry of sharp objects. It’s a smart design that protects without overdoing it, which is a common pitfall for some shoes in this category. You can tackle varied terrain with more confidence than you might expect.

Breathable And Lightweight Uppers

These shoes are incredibly light, which makes a huge difference on longer runs or when you’re just trying to move quickly. The uppers are designed to let your feet breathe, keeping them from getting too hot and sweaty, even on warmer days.

This breathability is a big plus for comfort, especially when you’re out on the trail for a while. It’s a simple feature, but it really contributes to the overall positive running experience, making them feel less like a burden and more like an extension of your foot. They are also quite packable, which is a nice bonus if you travel with your running gear like the HFS II.

The combination of a flexible sole, a foot-shaped toe box, and zero drop design means your feet can move naturally. This allows for better balance and agility on the trail, letting you adapt to changing surfaces with ease.

Weaknesses And Limitations

While the Xero Mesa Trail II is a fantastic minimalist option for many runners, it’s not without its drawbacks. Understanding these limitations will help you decide if it’s the right shoe for your specific needs and running style.

Laces Could Be Improved

The laces on the Mesa Trail II, while improved from the previous version, are still a bit peculiar. They tend to be a little slippery and don’t always stay tied as securely as one might hope, especially on longer runs or during more technical descents.

It’s a good idea to double-knot them or consider swapping them out for a more robust lacing system if this becomes an issue. This isn’t a deal-breaker for most, but it’s something to be aware of.

Not Ideal For Extreme Weather

These shoes are built for breathability and ground feel, which means they aren’t designed for harsh weather conditions. In deep snow or thick mud, the aggressive lugs might struggle to find purchase, and the lightweight, airy uppers offer little protection against the elements.

While they can handle light snow or damp trails, you’ll want to look elsewhere for serious winter running or extremely wet conditions. If you’re hitting the trails in the UK during winter, for instance, your feet will likely get quite wet and cold.

Forefoot Fit May Feel Slushy

Some runners have noted that the forefoot area, particularly around the lacing, can feel a bit slushy or less secure. This isn’t to say the shoe isn’t functional, but on steep downhills, if the laces haven’t been cinched down recently, there can be a slight sensation of your foot shifting a bit too much within the shoe.

It’s a minor point, but for those who demand absolute lockdown in every situation, it’s worth considering. This feeling is more pronounced if you have a wider toe splay, as the shoe might not offer the snug fit you’re accustomed to in the forefoot.

While the Mesa Trail II excels in many areas, its limitations in extreme weather and the potential for a less secure forefoot fit on steep descents are points to consider. For runners prioritizing maximum protection or a super-locked-down feel in all conditions, alternative options might be more suitable. However, for its intended purpose of natural, minimalist trail running, it remains a strong contender.

Who Should Consider The Xero Mesa Trail II

Ideal For Minimalist Enthusiasts

If you’re already deep into the world of minimalist or barefoot running, the Xero Mesa Trail II is definitely worth a look. It really nails that zero drop feel, letting your feet do their natural thing. It’s a shoe that lets you feel connected to the trail without sacrificing too much protection.

For those who appreciate a low-profile design and want to maintain that close-to-the-ground sensation on their runs, these are a solid choice. They’re a great option if you’re looking for a shoe that complements your existing minimalist running style. Many runners find these shoes provide a superior experience compared to their predecessors, making them a top pick for those already committed to this type of running.

Beginner Friendly Barefoot Option

Thinking about dipping your toes into minimalist running? The Mesa Trail II could be a good starting point. While it’s minimalist, it still offers enough protection underfoot that you don’t have to be overly cautious about every single rock or root.

The wider toe box allows your toes to spread out, which is a big plus for foot health and comfort, especially if you’re new to this. It’s a shoe that helps you get used to a more natural foot strike without feeling completely exposed. Just remember, conditioning your feet is still key, even with a shoe like this.

Who Should Avoid This Shoe

Now, these aren’t for everyone. If you’re someone who needs a lot of cushioning and support in your shoes, you’ll probably find the Mesa Trail II lacking. They’re also not the best bet for extreme weather conditions like deep snow or thick mud, as the uppers aren’t designed to keep your feet dry and warm in those situations.

People with very narrow feet might also find the fit a bit loose in the forefoot, even with the lacing adjustments. If you’re looking for a shoe that feels plush and highly structured, you might want to explore other options.

• Not for: Runners seeking maximum cushioning.
• Not for: Extreme cold or wet conditions.
• Not for: Those with exceptionally narrow feet who prefer a super snug forefoot.

While the Mesa Trail II offers a great balance for many, it’s important to match the shoe’s design to your personal running style and the conditions you typically encounter. If your runs often involve deep mud or icy trails, you might need something more specialized.

Conclusion

The Xero Mesa Trail II really shines for those who love that close-to-the-ground feel and want a shoe that lets their feet work naturally. They look good, feel light, and offer decent grip for most trails.

While they might not be the best for super muddy or snowy conditions, or for runners who need a lot of support, they are a solid choice for anyone getting into minimalist running or for experienced barefoot runners looking for a versatile trail shoe. They’re a great option for getting out there and enjoying the trails with less between you and the earth.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are the Xero Mesa Trail II good for beginners?

Yes, they can be a good starting point for beginners who want to try minimalist running. They offer some protection while still letting you feel the ground. Just make sure your feet are ready for less support.

How do they handle wet or muddy trails?

They do okay in light mud or wet conditions, but they aren’t really made for deep mud or slippery ice. The treads can get clogged, and the uppers aren’t waterproof, so your feet could get wet and cold.

Is the toe box wide enough?

Xero Shoes are known for having a roomy toe box, and the Mesa Trail II is no different. Your toes should have plenty of space to spread out, which is great for natural foot movement.

Do these shoes have arch support?

No, these are minimalist shoes, meaning they don’t have built-in arch support or thick cushioning like regular running shoes. The idea is to let your foot muscles do the work.

Are they comfortable for everyday wear?

Many people find minimalist shoes comfortable for walking around, and the Mesa Trail II is no exception. They’re light and flexible, so they can be worn casually, but they are designed for running.

What’s the main difference between version 1 and version 2?

The Mesa Trail II is a bit lighter than the first version. It also has some updated materials and design touches, like more durable overlays on the upper, making it a bit tougher and sleeker.